For several days now, debate has ranged back and forth on the Quiltart list in response to a writer who commented how disappointed she was that the well known magazine  Quilting Arts was so heavily technique and specific project focused (materials, patterns, instructions) rather than on the ‘art’ inspiration, design concepts, etc implied in its title.   I’m not a subscriber, but  from time to time when visiting the USA I have picked up a current copy to see what’s going on there, and have always known  it is not a magazine for me to take regularly.  However, it suits a lot of people, and so I went to the website Quilting Arts and found this mission statement: “Welcome to the online community just for comtemporary quilters.”   That seems fine to me – the magazine lives up to the expectations of the many contemporary quiltmakers who for various reasons are making quilts not only in traditional styles but branching out into other ways of working, some of which depend on modern technology, digital and mechanical.  Many of the articles are ‘how to’ use these new techniques.

The Quiltart list is “an internet mailing list … for contemporary art quilters – as a means for those interested in innovative contemporary art quilting to share learn and grow”    With around 3000 members,  naturally they represent the full spectrum of quilters from careful skilled technicians to exhuberant but possibly not technically gifted makers,  and everything in between.  As someone said, if Quilting Arts magazine is not for you, don’t read it – and the same can be said for the books, videos and tv programmes that the quilting industry makes available for people to follow and learn from current trends in this particular area of quilting.

So there’s a lot of hot air exercised over the ‘art’ in quilt making – and those of us who aren’t too fazed about this just get on with what we’re going to do, anyway!  But in all the hooha expressed this week, one of the silliest, vaccuous, reasons I read of why someone declared she was a proud subscriber of this magazine was  something along the lines of her rarely if ever actually reading her copy, but she continues her subscription as ‘an expression of  support’ .  Ye gods, with sentimental emotive claptrap like that flying around, I think the magazine and others like it have a good future – quilters as a group are very sentimental.    But, seriously the magazine is a good one if you are wanting to learn some of the popular techniques being used in contemporary  of  ‘how to’ publications.  I predict as long as quiltmaking thrives, so will magazines like it.  While the makers will stick with the innovative project articles, which do after all sell, more mature artists will probably drop such publications altogether as their vision grows – their need for technical information diminishes, and their works increasingly depend on  exploration, observation and reflection of the world around them.  Rather than read about what others are doing,  people who want to make make art will find some way to get the effect they want or need if it is really important to what they want to achieve.

POSTSCRIPT:

This discussion is settling down, and magazines such as Quilting Arts are part of the Quilting Industry in just the same way as quilt shops, pattern designers, assemblers of kits, people who design gadgets and tools to make the job of the  modern quilter easier, writers of articles and people who demonstrate and teach, historians, valuers, judges, fabric designers and manufacturers, event organisers, and many more.  Of course, all these people tend to have detractors from within the Dedicated Traditionalists Group – (by which I mean those who proudly declare they only ever piece by hand, and then make a delicate little sniffing sound to confirm their purist statements, LOL, as if anyone gives a hoot!)   The point is, there is room for all of them in the Quilting Industry.

Now, the Quilting Industry and all that goes on there is not necessarily anything to do with Art.  It can be of course, but isn’t necessarily.  Because of the traditional crafts background from which many modern quilt makers have come to the more innovative even artistically inspired quilted textile works, many motivated art quilters  still have angst separating, cutting the apron strings if you like, from ties that bind them to their traditional background.  If you want to make textile art, it can even be an advantage if you don’t have any quilting heritage at all in your background.